A recent New York Times article by Susan Saulny and Published: March 29, 2009, documented several cases of a relatively new phenomenon – banks just walking away from foreclosed properties. Susan documented several cases around the country where banks had started foreclosure processes and even scheduled the sheriff’s sale, only to cancel that sale at the last minute and then quietly walk away.
In the cases that Ms. Saulny documented the previous owners had already moved out and in at least one case the house had been vandalized and stripped by thieves. There in lays the root of the problem – the houses were then worth less than the banks thought it would cost them to pursue the full course of the foreclosure. That’s not hard to see, Locally we have foreclosed homes selling for under $5,000 in Detroit and Pontiac (and likely in Ypsilanti). That’s below what one would think the land is worth; however, there is the cost of tearing down the existing structure, which could exceed the cost of the house. And if one did create a vacant lot right now, that likely wouldn’t sell either, since there is little building going on and that lot would be in the middle of a depressed area.
The second shoe that the article pointed out has dropped on the former homeowners is that the cities where these homes are located can’t find anyone else to hold responsible, so they go after the former owners with bills for cleanup or maintenance or for violation of other ordinances. They do that because the sheriff’s sale didn’t take place and the title is still in the name of the previous owner. Wouldn’t that be a kick in the pants? You just got thrown out of your house and now the city says you’re responsible for the stripped hulk that remains. In some of the cases documented by the Times article the lender had gone out of business ands there was no way to track anybody else down.
I guess people who get foreclosed should try to stay in place as long as possible, to see whether the bank is really going to go all the way through the process. In Michigan a foreclosed owner gets to remain in the house rent-free for 6 months after the Sheriff’s sale and even at the end of that “redemption period” would get a few days notice to move upon eviction proceedings.
It’s not clear what the real legal status of these homes would be, if the bank walks away. I would assume that, if the previous owner had kept current on things like taxes and utilities, and there had been no Sheriff’s sale, then the title remains with the previous owner and they could continue to occupy the place. They might have trouble trying to sell it though, since there would likely not be any discharge of the foreclosure ever recorded. This is probably legal fodder for many court cases. Have you seen any of this happening where you are? What was the outcome?
Showing posts with label foreclosure mess. Show all posts
Showing posts with label foreclosure mess. Show all posts
Thursday, April 2, 2009
Saturday, February 21, 2009
We’re slipping in the rankings and that’s good!
RealtyTrac® (realtytrac.com), the leading online marketplace for foreclosure properties, last week released its January 2009 U.S. Foreclosure Market Report™, which shows foreclosure filings — default notices, auction sale notices and bank repossessions — were reported on 274,399 U.S. properties during the month, a 10 percent decrease from the previous month but still up 18 percent from January 2008. The report also shows one in every 466 U.S. housing units received a foreclosure filing in January. The good news, if it can be called that, is that Michigan has slipped out of the top 5 foreclosure states and now ranks only # 7 in the U.S. Yea!
“The extensive foreclosure efforts on the part of lenders and government agencies appear to have impacted the January numbers — particularly the Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac moratorium on all foreclosure sales that was extended through the end of January along with Florida’s voluntary 45-day freeze on all new foreclosure actions and scheduling of foreclosure sales that was announced at the beginning of December,” said James J. Saccacio, chief executive officer of RealtyTrac. “January REOs, which represent completed foreclosure sales to the foreclosing lender, were down 15 percent nationwide from the previous month. And in Florida overall foreclosure activity was down 20 percent from the previous month.”
Nevada, California, Arizona posted the top state foreclosure rates
Nevada foreclosure activity in January decreased 4 percent from the previous month, but the state continued to register the nation’s No. 1 foreclosure rate, with one in every 76 housing units receiving a foreclosure filing during the month. Foreclosure filings were reported on 14,444 Nevada properties in January, up 137 percent from January 2008.
California posted the nation’s second highest state foreclosure rate in January, with one in every 173 housing units receiving a foreclosure filing during the month, and Arizona posted the nation’s third highest state foreclosure rate, with one in every 182 housing units receiving a foreclosure filing during the month.
Despite a 20 percent month-over-month drop in foreclosure activity, Florida posted the nation’s fourth highest state foreclosure rate, with one in every 214 housing units receiving a foreclosure filing during the month.
Other states with foreclosure rates ranking among the nation’s 10 highest were Oregon, Illinois, Michigan, Georgia, Idaho and Ohio. You know times are tough when it feels good to be among the “also ran” category. Now the challenge is to get the overhang of foreclosed properties off the market, so that regular houses have a chance to sell again. Some of the upcoming HUD programs to spend Federal money to help make that happen should help.
Who knows, maybe we can fight our way out of the top ten. Wouldn't that be great? For the full report on the January foreclosure rates in all of the states, click here.
“The extensive foreclosure efforts on the part of lenders and government agencies appear to have impacted the January numbers — particularly the Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac moratorium on all foreclosure sales that was extended through the end of January along with Florida’s voluntary 45-day freeze on all new foreclosure actions and scheduling of foreclosure sales that was announced at the beginning of December,” said James J. Saccacio, chief executive officer of RealtyTrac. “January REOs, which represent completed foreclosure sales to the foreclosing lender, were down 15 percent nationwide from the previous month. And in Florida overall foreclosure activity was down 20 percent from the previous month.”
Nevada, California, Arizona posted the top state foreclosure rates
Nevada foreclosure activity in January decreased 4 percent from the previous month, but the state continued to register the nation’s No. 1 foreclosure rate, with one in every 76 housing units receiving a foreclosure filing during the month. Foreclosure filings were reported on 14,444 Nevada properties in January, up 137 percent from January 2008.
California posted the nation’s second highest state foreclosure rate in January, with one in every 173 housing units receiving a foreclosure filing during the month, and Arizona posted the nation’s third highest state foreclosure rate, with one in every 182 housing units receiving a foreclosure filing during the month.
Despite a 20 percent month-over-month drop in foreclosure activity, Florida posted the nation’s fourth highest state foreclosure rate, with one in every 214 housing units receiving a foreclosure filing during the month.
Other states with foreclosure rates ranking among the nation’s 10 highest were Oregon, Illinois, Michigan, Georgia, Idaho and Ohio. You know times are tough when it feels good to be among the “also ran” category. Now the challenge is to get the overhang of foreclosed properties off the market, so that regular houses have a chance to sell again. Some of the upcoming HUD programs to spend Federal money to help make that happen should help.
Who knows, maybe we can fight our way out of the top ten. Wouldn't that be great? For the full report on the January foreclosure rates in all of the states, click here.
Friday, November 7, 2008
Unemployment driving foreclosures now.
From a recent CNN Money report on the real estate market comes this report. As the economy tanks, unemployment is the major factor driving a much larger proportion of foreclosures now than in the earlier stages of the mortgage meltdown, when bad loans were primarily to blame.
In June, 45.5% of all delinquencies reported by Freddie Mac (FRE, Fortune 500) were due to unemployment or the loss of income, according to the company. That's a rise from a level of 36.3% in 2006.
"The two economic factors that most contribute to foreclosures are falling home prices and rising unemployment," said Richard DeKaser, chief economist for National City Corp (NCC, Fortune 500). "It's hard to pay your mortgage when you don't have a job."
And that's a situation that more and more people are finding themselves in. Nearly one million Americans have lost their jobs so far in 2008. The Bureau of Labor Statistics reported in early October that 159,000 private sector jobs were lost in September, and on Friday, economists expect the BLS to report that 200,000 jobs were lost in October.
"The rise in job losses will increase and extend the delinquency trend," said Doug Duncan, the chief economist for mortgage giant Fannie Mae (FNM, Fortune 500). Foreclosures spiked 71% in September alone according to RealtyTrac.
A double whammy
Of course the housing crisis is driving unemployment which in turn has exacerbated the housing crisis - particularly in bubble states like Florida, Nevada and Arizona.
The unemployment rate in Florida was just 3.3% in May 2006, when the subprime crisis began to emerge - far below the national average of 4.7% at the time. Today Florida's rate stands at 6.6%, well above the current national average of 6.1%. And, Michigan leads the nation with an 8.7% unemployment rate at the end of September.
The employment issues in Michigan are driven by the automotive industry, which is in such sad shape that there is open talk of one or more of the local auto companies going out of business. Hopes now hang on a federal bailout and a merger between GM and Chrysler.
In our area the UAW auto members who fueled much of the housing boom are now experiencing life without much overtime and layoffs that likely impact 1 in 10 families, when supplier layoffs are added in. Not only aren't they buying any more, but many are in the process of losing the homes that they bought in better times to foreclosure. And all of those automotive execs who used to provide a buyer pool for upscale, move-up houses - forgetaboutit!
So 2009 is shaping up to be the year of the layoff foreclosure. Whatever causes them, foreclosures will continue to put downward pricing and value pressure on the market. It doesn't really matter if the bank is willing to rework the loan or if the Feds programs provide for new lower rates; if the homeowner doesn't have a job, anything above a zero payment is likely out of the question. WE NEED JOBS IN MICHIGAN! Then we can worry about real estate.
In June, 45.5% of all delinquencies reported by Freddie Mac (FRE, Fortune 500) were due to unemployment or the loss of income, according to the company. That's a rise from a level of 36.3% in 2006.
"The two economic factors that most contribute to foreclosures are falling home prices and rising unemployment," said Richard DeKaser, chief economist for National City Corp (NCC, Fortune 500). "It's hard to pay your mortgage when you don't have a job."
And that's a situation that more and more people are finding themselves in. Nearly one million Americans have lost their jobs so far in 2008. The Bureau of Labor Statistics reported in early October that 159,000 private sector jobs were lost in September, and on Friday, economists expect the BLS to report that 200,000 jobs were lost in October.
"The rise in job losses will increase and extend the delinquency trend," said Doug Duncan, the chief economist for mortgage giant Fannie Mae (FNM, Fortune 500). Foreclosures spiked 71% in September alone according to RealtyTrac.
A double whammy
Of course the housing crisis is driving unemployment which in turn has exacerbated the housing crisis - particularly in bubble states like Florida, Nevada and Arizona.
The unemployment rate in Florida was just 3.3% in May 2006, when the subprime crisis began to emerge - far below the national average of 4.7% at the time. Today Florida's rate stands at 6.6%, well above the current national average of 6.1%. And, Michigan leads the nation with an 8.7% unemployment rate at the end of September.
The employment issues in Michigan are driven by the automotive industry, which is in such sad shape that there is open talk of one or more of the local auto companies going out of business. Hopes now hang on a federal bailout and a merger between GM and Chrysler.
In our area the UAW auto members who fueled much of the housing boom are now experiencing life without much overtime and layoffs that likely impact 1 in 10 families, when supplier layoffs are added in. Not only aren't they buying any more, but many are in the process of losing the homes that they bought in better times to foreclosure. And all of those automotive execs who used to provide a buyer pool for upscale, move-up houses - forgetaboutit!
So 2009 is shaping up to be the year of the layoff foreclosure. Whatever causes them, foreclosures will continue to put downward pricing and value pressure on the market. It doesn't really matter if the bank is willing to rework the loan or if the Feds programs provide for new lower rates; if the homeowner doesn't have a job, anything above a zero payment is likely out of the question. WE NEED JOBS IN MICHIGAN! Then we can worry about real estate.
Friday, September 19, 2008
Foreclosure fever still with us…
From a couple of different news feeds that I get comes this story about the still rising foreclosure crisis in America. RealtyTrac, the leading online marketplace for foreclosure properties, has reported that filings increased 12 percent in August from just July. The figures are 27 percent above August 2007 numbers.
“In August the total number of U.S. properties that received foreclosure filings as well as the national foreclosure rate were both the highest we’ve seen in any month since we began issuing our report in January 2005; however, the annual increase of 27 percent was actually substantially lower than in previous months this year, when it was hovering around 50 to 65 percent,” said James J. Saccacio, chief executive officer of RealtyTrac. These numbers are showing that 1 in every 416 U.S. homes received a foreclosure filing.
Certain states have an even higher rate of foreclosures. Nevada holds the lead at 1 in every 91 homes. Michigan has slipped in the rankings number 6, with 1 home in every 490 being in foreclosure; and that’s a good thing.
Economist David Shulman of the UCLA Anderson Forecast says he thinks foreclosures will continue to rise for the remainder of the year as more adjustable-rate mortgages reset, including more so-called "no-doc" loans, which don't require verification of borrowers' income.
Rick Sharga, vice president of RealtyTrac, expects a 35% to 40% jump in foreclosure filings this year over last year.
Some areas are suffering much more than others. Five states -- California, Florida, Texas, Michigan and Ohio -- together accounted for 50% of the nation's total foreclosures in March, according to RealtyTrac. But it was Nevada, Colorado and California that had the top three foreclosure rates for March.
Among cities, California's Stockton was No. 1, with one foreclosure in every 128 households -- a 137% spike from February. Las Vegas, with 4,307 filings, had the nation's second-highest metro foreclosure rate in March, with one foreclosure filing for every 139 households -- more than five times the national average. Other metro areas with foreclosure rates among the nation's 10 highest included Greeley, Colo. (No. 4); Detroit (No. 8) and Denver (No. 9). For a full story from MSN and the complete list of where the fifty state rank in the foreclosure derby, click here.
“In August the total number of U.S. properties that received foreclosure filings as well as the national foreclosure rate were both the highest we’ve seen in any month since we began issuing our report in January 2005; however, the annual increase of 27 percent was actually substantially lower than in previous months this year, when it was hovering around 50 to 65 percent,” said James J. Saccacio, chief executive officer of RealtyTrac. These numbers are showing that 1 in every 416 U.S. homes received a foreclosure filing.
Certain states have an even higher rate of foreclosures. Nevada holds the lead at 1 in every 91 homes. Michigan has slipped in the rankings number 6, with 1 home in every 490 being in foreclosure; and that’s a good thing.
Economist David Shulman of the UCLA Anderson Forecast says he thinks foreclosures will continue to rise for the remainder of the year as more adjustable-rate mortgages reset, including more so-called "no-doc" loans, which don't require verification of borrowers' income.
Rick Sharga, vice president of RealtyTrac, expects a 35% to 40% jump in foreclosure filings this year over last year.
Some areas are suffering much more than others. Five states -- California, Florida, Texas, Michigan and Ohio -- together accounted for 50% of the nation's total foreclosures in March, according to RealtyTrac. But it was Nevada, Colorado and California that had the top three foreclosure rates for March.
Among cities, California's Stockton was No. 1, with one foreclosure in every 128 households -- a 137% spike from February. Las Vegas, with 4,307 filings, had the nation's second-highest metro foreclosure rate in March, with one foreclosure filing for every 139 households -- more than five times the national average. Other metro areas with foreclosure rates among the nation's 10 highest included Greeley, Colo. (No. 4); Detroit (No. 8) and Denver (No. 9). For a full story from MSN and the complete list of where the fifty state rank in the foreclosure derby, click here.
I can certainly attest to the fact that foreclosures are what most of my buyers want to go see these days and there is no lack of houses to show them. The other thing that appears to be happening in this market, at least locally; is that banks, scared by what has happened recently to some of the largest holders of foreclosed properties, are now in full dump 'em mode. Prices have tumbled on foreclosed houses as the banks try to unload them before they are dragged down by them. Hopefully that will clear out the inventory overhang of these properties. It's still a great time to be a buyer, but this won't last forever; so, get in the market now to get the best choices on great deals.
Friday, August 10, 2007
Are we there yet? Are we there yet?
The title line above is often used in reference to kids on a car trip, but lately it could also apply to sellers who are looking for the bottom of the current slide of home values. We likely aren't there yet. Prices haven't bottomed out quite yet and may not for some time. There are a variety of reasons, but right now the biggest contributor seems to be the overhang of foreclosed houses that banks are starting to unload.
For a while the banks held on to the hope that they could get their money out of these properties. Now they just seem to want out, at whatever price they can get. So, many are dumping houses at 60-70 cents on the dollar, some even less. I've shown a number of foreclosed houses lately that are in fairly good condition, some even brand new, that are selling for $60-80-even 100,000 less than they were on the market for less than a year ago. I'll admit that a number of the foreclosures that I've shown also need about that much work or repairs to them, especially if they've set empty for a year or more. But a number really needed nothing more than a few light fixtures or some touch-up painting.
This avalanche of cheap, foreclosed houses is starting to discourage regular home sellers who don't have the ability to absorb a loss like the banks do. That is having an unintended side effect that may temporarily contribute to a correction in the market. Discouraged regular home sellers who don't have to sell are starting to take their homes back off the market, determined to wait out this mess. If enough sellers do that the current inventory glut will be relieved a little bit. It looks like the current round of ARM resets, where the cheap Adjustable Rate Mortgages of a few years back adjust upward, will go on for the rest of this year and into next. It's those adjustments that are driving many home owners over the brink and into foreclosure. Unless the banks and/or the government do something to provide some relief, we'll likely be feeling this foreclosure issue and its impact on the real estate market well into next year.
So, are we there yet? No. In fact it's hard to even see that we're half way there yet. But, if you have one of those ARM time bombs ticking away in a desk drawer somewhere in your house, get it out and do something about it before it goes off. try working with your lender first. But, if that doesn't work and you can see that you're going to need to get out from under your house, get with your Realtor and get started on a plan to sell the place before the foreclosure process starts.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)

