Translate

Showing posts with label home valuation. Show all posts
Showing posts with label home valuation. Show all posts

Tuesday, April 5, 2011

Using distressed sales as comps – some states say no…

In today’s RealtyTimes email is a story by Bob Hunt about several states passing or looking at passing laws that try to govern how appraisers might use (include or not include and how to factor) distressed sales – foreclosures and short sales. Click here to read the entire article.

The legislators in the states involved undoubtedly believe that they have the best interests of their citizen at heart – legislators, after all, always seem to think that they know what’s best for us. However, as Hunt points out in the article, these state laws may put the appraisers at odds with Federal laws which state that they must use all available sales in establishing the local market pricing. Hunt goes on to point out some of the complexities that appraisers already need to figure out in order to comply with the Federal guidelines under the Uniform Standards of Professional Appraisal Practice (USPAP), and how these new state rules would further complicate things.


Hunt uses the figures 30-40% of all sales as his measure of what percentage of all sales involve distressed properties. In my area that is still running well about 50% and reaches as high as 70% in some markets. It would be almost impossible to find enough comps to do an analysis without using distressed properties in my markets. The challenge for Realtors® and appraisers alike is figuring out how to factor in the impact of neglect or intentional damage to these distressed houses when using them as comps.


One might make the argument that even if one is diligent in not using distressed homes as comps they still have a large impact on value, since they are now heavily influencing assessments in most areas, causing home values to continue to drop. It is also somewhat ingenuous to think that these homes are not a major part of any local market, especially in my area where they make up such a large portion of the actual sales. I have seen figures that show that they make up less than 25% of the overall inventory on the market in my area and yet they constitute 50-70% of the actual sales in 8 out f the 9 markets that I track.


When I’m doing CMA’s for local clients I try to take out the most egregious examples of distressed homes – those maybe selling for $40-50/Sq Ft in a neighborhood that averages $90-100/Sq Ft. Those are usually the homes that have been trashed or stripped by angry ex-owners and should not be included. I trend to leave short sales in the analysis and foreclosed homes that look like they brought reasonable prices. Those are arbitrary calls on my part, but then the whole home valuation process is much more arbitrary these days that in “normal times”, whatever that was.

Tuesday, November 13, 2007

Putting a value on your home


One of the more difficult things to do these days is getting the right value (price) on homes that are going on the market. Even appraisers are having some difficulty getting value right. A part of the problem is caused by the slow turn-over in the market. It may be hard to find a comparable home that has sold within a reasonable period of time and close to the home in question. Realtors and appraisers like to find "comps" within a mile or two, preferably in the same neighborhood or sub. Obviously finding some sold homes that are almost exactly like the one in question is the best case scenario; however, even that case goes out the window if more than 3-4 months have passed since the sales. The market has been too dynamic (unfortunately in a downward direction) to use comps that more than 1-2 months old.

So, I depend quite a bit on statistics to help me guide sellers. If I can find comparable houses, that's great; otherwise, I look at what has sold in the last 2-3 months (6 months at the outside), even if not exactly comparable, and then calculate what people have been paying on a cost per square foot basis in the area of interest. It's a pretty good bet that if the area average is $100/Sq Ft that putting a house on the market in the same area for $150/Sq Ft is going to be a tough sell.

Now, it's certainly possible that the owners have put the upgrades and updates into the house to justify trying to get the price uplift; however, many times it ends up that owners just can't get back what they think they should for a place, because the surrounding neighborhood just doesn't justify the premium. I've seen that quite often lately with house-flippers (people who buy houses in need of repair/updating, do the work quickly and then try to sell them). Many house-flippers have been badly burned by the cu rent market and some have even slipped into foreclosure on properties that they were sure that they could flip with a few updates. It's actually not good to be the most expensive home in your neighborhood.

If you're considering selling within the next 6 months, it would be a good idea to call a good Realtor (and you already know one from reading this blog) and having him/her come in and give you an analysis of the current value of your home and make suggestions about what you could do to improve it and get it ready for the market.